GOOD SHOES. REAL LIFE. An independent guide for men 35+ Research in progress
Gentle Sneaker
THE EVERYDAY SHOE EDIT
Our approach ↗

Asics GEL-NYC

For men 35+: fit, comfort, weather and wear.

AsicsChunky shape

Asics GEL-NYC

Image: ASICS

Reviews

15 of 17 reviews recommend it.

2 do not recommend it.

Overall review score7.8/1015 authors

GEL-NYC

  • True to size or small
  • Feels light

2.0

  • True to size or small; wide
  • Feels light

$150Mid-rangeprice at the maker's store

Find on Google

On our lists: Sneakers that wear wide · Lightweight sneakers

Do Asics GEL-NYC run big?

Length

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
21

Reported sensations

  1. Width

    • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

    GEL-NYC

    • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
    • Narrow fit.

    2.0

    • Wide fit.

  2. Around the toes

    • Reported rubbing.
    • Reports differ: snug or tight.

    2.0

    • Roomy.

Are Asics GEL-NYC comfortable all day?

Through the day

  • All dayComfortable.

Weight on foot

  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.

Do they feel hot in warm weather?

In warm weather

GEL-NYC

  • Feels cool.

How do they hold up over time?

What wears or breaks?

12
Reported locations, not a failure rate.

1Upper

  • Coming apart, tearing.

2Stitching

  • Broken.

Will they keep their looks?

  • Holds up with wear.

See them on video

YouTube ↗

Asics Gel-NYC 2.0 "Cream / Concrete": Review & On-Feet

YouTube ↗

ASICS GEL- NYC 2.0 | Detailed Review : Sizing, Fitting, comfort, Price & On-feet |

YouTube ↗

One of The Most Comfortable Sneakers I've Ever Tried: Asics Gel-NYC

YouTube ↗

ASICS Gel-NYC Review & On Feet: The Most COMFORTABLE Lifestyle Sneaker of the Year?

ASICS GEL-NYC 2.0 Review: Lifestyle Sneaker Lebih Ringan ... by thekasutshow

ASICS GEL NYC Cream Cloud Grey Review and Outfits

Enjoy A Closer Look at these Asics Gel-NYC in “Cream/Antique ... by N O U V E A U

More videos
YouTube ↗

ASICS Gel NYC 2 is a GAME CHANGER 🔥 The New Standard for Comfort Sneakers

YouTube ↗

ASICS GEL NYC | THE BEST FALL AND WINTER SHOE? ❄️👟☃️

YouTube ↗

Why These Shoes Might REPLACE Your Favourite Kicks - Asics GEL NYC

YouTube ↗

Asics Gel NYC Cream Oyster Grey | review & on feet

YouTube ↗

HOW TO LACE ASICS GEL-NYC | LOOSE LACING TUTORIAL (BEST WAY!)

YouTube ↗

The ASICS Collab of the year? - HIDDEN NY ASICS GEL NYC Review & On Feet

YouTube ↗

Asics Gel-NYC "Concrete / Oatmeal": Review & On-Feet

YouTube ↗

Asics Gel NYC Birch Pure Silver | review & on feet

YouTube ↗

Asics Gel NYC Black/Clay Grey | review & on feet

Estimate your cost per wear
Your scenario

What would each wear cost you?

Enter your price, frequency and expected years.Your assumptions · not the model’s measured lifespan
How this is calculated

Price ÷ (days per week × 52 × years), with one wear per day, rounded up to the next cent. Price and lifespan here are your scenario, not observations from other owners.

About our research

Based on 27 reviews and other sources.

We compare owner feedback and reviews for fit, comfort and wear. Model details come from maker and retail information.

How we put the guide together →

Compare with similar pairs

Similar uses, different fits and trade-offs. These are reports about each model, not a head-to-head test.

Asics GEL-NYC vs Asics GEL-1130

Also used for walking. Compare toe box.
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-1130
Asics GEL-1130See this model
What mattersAsics GEL-NYCAsics GEL-1130
Length
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
  • True to size.

GEL-1130

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
Width
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

GEL-NYC

  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Narrow fit.

2.0

  • Wide fit.
  • wide feetReports differ: narrow or regular.
  • Reports differ: narrow, regular or wide.
Toe box
  • Reports differ: snug or tight.

2.0

  • Roomy.
  • Reports differ: roomy or snug.
All day on your feet
  • All dayComfortable.
  • All day walkingComfortable.
  • All dayComfortable.
Weight on the foot
  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.
  • Feels light.

GEL-1130

  • Feels light.
Maker price$150 (price at the maker's store)$110 (price at the maker's store)

Maker prices recorded 2026-09-26.

Asics GEL-NYC vs Asics GEL-CUMULUS 16

Also used for walking. Compare length.
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-CUMULUS 16
Asics GEL-CUMULUS 16See this model
What mattersAsics GEL-NYCAsics GEL-CUMULUS 16
Length
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
  • Reports differ: true to size or large.
Width
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

GEL-NYC

  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Narrow fit.

2.0

  • Wide fit.
  • Reports differ: narrow, regular or wide.
Toe box
  • Reports differ: snug or tight.

2.0

  • Roomy.
  • Roomy.
All day on your feet
  • All dayComfortable.
  • All dayComfortable.
Weight on the foot
  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.
  • Feels light.
Maker price$150 (price at the maker's store)$140–$150 (price at the maker's store)

Maker prices recorded 2026-09-26 / 2026-09-25.

Asics GEL-NYC vs Asics Gel-Kayano 14

Also used for walking. Compare length.
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics Gel-Kayano 14
Asics Gel-Kayano 14See this model
What mattersAsics GEL-NYCAsics Gel-Kayano 14
Length
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
Width
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

GEL-NYC

  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Narrow fit.

2.0

  • Wide fit.
  • narrow feetSnug across the foot.
  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Reports differ: narrow, regular or wide.
Toe box
  • Reports differ: snug or tight.

2.0

  • Roomy.
  • wide feetRoomy.
  • Reports differ: roomy or snug.
All day on your feet
  • All dayComfortable.
  • All day standingComfortable.
  • All day walking · cold weatherComfortable.
Weight on the foot
  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.
  • Feels light.
Maker price$150 (price at the maker's store)$150 (regular price at the maker's store)

Maker prices recorded 2026-09-26 / 2026-09-28.

Asics GEL-NYC vs Asics Gel-Nimbus 10.1

Also used for walking. Compare length.
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics Gel-Nimbus 10.1
Asics Gel-Nimbus 10.1See this model
What mattersAsics GEL-NYCAsics Gel-Nimbus 10.1
Length
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
  • Reports differ: small, true to size or large.
Width
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

GEL-NYC

  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Narrow fit.

2.0

  • Wide fit.
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.
Toe box
  • Reports differ: snug or tight.

2.0

  • Roomy.
  • Roomy.
All day on your feet
  • All dayComfortable.
  • All day walkingComfortable.
Weight on the foot
  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.
  • Feels light to some wearers, heavy to others.
Maker price$150 (price at the maker's store)$160–$170 (regular price at the maker's store)

Maker prices recorded 2026-09-26 / 2026-09-28.

Asics GEL-NYC vs Asics GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIII

Also used for walking. Compare length.
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIII
Asics GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIIISee this model
What mattersAsics GEL-NYCAsics GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIII
Length
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
  • Reports differ: true to size or large.

GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIII

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
Width
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

GEL-NYC

  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Narrow fit.

2.0

  • Wide fit.
  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Reports differ: regular or wide.
Toe box
  • Reports differ: snug or tight.

2.0

  • Roomy.
  • wide feetRoomy.

GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIII

  • Snug.
All day on your feet
  • All dayComfortable.
  • All day standingComfortable.
Weight on the foot
  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.
  • Feels light.

GEL-QUANTUM 360 VIII

  • Feels light.
Maker price$150 (price at the maker's store)$170–$190 (regular price at the maker's store)

Maker prices recorded 2026-09-26.

Asics GEL-NYC vs Asics Japan S

Also used for walking. Compare length.
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics GEL-NYC
Asics Japan S
Asics Japan SSee this model
What mattersAsics GEL-NYCAsics Japan S
Length
  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

GEL-NYC

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.

2.0

  • Reports differ: small or true to size.
  • Reports differ: small, true to size or large.
Width
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.

GEL-NYC

  • wide feetRoomy across the foot.
  • Narrow fit.

2.0

  • Wide fit.
  • Reports differ: narrow or regular.
Toe box
  • Reports differ: snug or tight.

2.0

  • Roomy.
  • Roomy.
All day on your feet
  • All dayComfortable.
  • All day standingComfortable.
  • All day walkingComfortable.
Weight on the foot
  • Feels heavy.

GEL-NYC

  • Feels light.

2.0

  • Feels light.
  • Reports differ: light or heavy.
Maker price$150 (price at the maker's store)$85 (regular price at the maker's store)

Maker prices recorded 2026-09-26 / 2026-09-28.

More about Asics

Asics in our guide: chunky, court, runner, skate, terrace, trail lifestyle and trainer shapes. Explore the range and compare individual pairs.

Explore Asics

You might also like

More chunky shapes to explore. Open a pair for its fit and wear details.

Mizuno Wave Rider 10

Mizuno Wave Rider 10

Converse Run Star Legacy CX

Converse Run Star Legacy CX

New Balance 9060

New Balance 9060

Nike Air Monarch IV

Nike Air Monarch IV

Asics GEL-NYC 2055Image: Huckberry

Asics GEL-NYC 2055

Asics GEL-NIMBUS 9Image: farfetch.com

Asics GEL-NIMBUS 9

More brands to explore

Other makers with chunky shapes in our catalogue.

Updated Sep 2026 · How we research